Dear Quote Investigator : Recently I was invited to conduct a workshop about writing and creativity. While reviewing materials on this topic I repeatedly came across a humorous quotation that pertains to commercialism.
Here is one version:. Writing is like sex.
I did it for my own pleasure. then i did it for my friends. now i do it for money
First you do it for love, then you do it for your friends, and then you do it for money. These words were credited to Virginia Woolf which frankly I found very unlikely. Quote Investigator van buren palmerston prostitution Congratulations on your sleuthing skills. I think that one of the names you give belongs to the true originator of this quip. Different versions of this quotation have been used by creative artists in multiple disciplines. The Abstract Expressionist painter Ad Reinhardt, famous for his uncompromising philosophy of art that led to canvases covered with shades of black, used a version of the saying in the s.
But he did not originate the saying, and he placed quotation marks around it.
Van buren palmerston prostitution
An anecdote set in the s about the acclaimed photographer Philippe Halsman contained a version of the quotation. He also created many of the cover shots for Life magazine. Rudolf Kommer and I, in the little garden of a coffee-house in the Austrian Tyrol. Then I did it for the pleasure of my friends. And now—I do it for money. Molnar has a well-deserved reputation as a raconteur and a wit. Once an interviewer asked him to explain his development as a dramatist. First I did it to please myself, then Van buren palmerston prostitution did it to please my friends, and now I do it for money.
But it is an unusually frank admission that he has at times pandered to the public taste …. An article by famed columnist Nat Hentoff discussed the work of crime fiction writer Ed Lacy.
At the front of the book, by the way, Lacy has printed the book is about a free-lance writer this exposition, ascribed by him to Moliere:. QI specializes in tracing quotations in the English language. The eleventh rule stated the following [AR]:. Reinhardt placed the saying in quotation marks, and he did not provide an attribution.
In later years the words were sometimes attributed directly to him. An anecdote set in claims that the prominent photographer Philippe Halsman used a version of the quotation when he discussed his career choice.
The story about Halsman was told by R. Smith Schuneman, Professor of Journalism, at a conference on photocommunication in Further below an excerpt from a memoir by the actor Leonard Nimoy provides additional evidence that Halsman has used the saying https://alatkantor.site/rss.xml:.
One comedian par excellence has disguised himself for years as a photographer. I discovered that. His name, of course, is Mr. Philippe had this answer for panel chairman Harriet Shepard in when she asked him why he became a photographer:. Well, I drifted into photography like one drifts into prostitution. First, I did it to please myself; then I did it to please my friends; and, eventually, I did it for money!
That Hungarian guy, Molnar, he once made a crack. It got a big laugh. I remember. Still does. He said becoming a writer is like becoming a whore. First you do it for your own pleasure, then you do it for the pleasure of a few friends, and finally you do it for money. First I did it to please myself, then Van buren palmerston prostitution did it to please my friends, and finally I did it for money.
Another chronique to help you keep up with the spate of books published in our field. More writing to notice, more writing for me.
The visit occurred twenty years before the publication of the memoir [LN]:. He had started with love, and ended up with commerce. No specific citation was given in the reference, and the words differed from the earliest version given above [ODLQ]:. In the same way that a woman becomes a prostitute. The connection of Virginia Woolf to the saying appears to be rather recent.
Better whore [. In the celebrity chef Anthony Bourdain was interviewed in Time magazine and he used a version of the quip [ABT]:.
The clinical relevance of oliguria in the critically ill patient: analysis of a large observational database
Then you do it for a few friends. Finally you do it for money. Evidence also indicates that Philippe Halsman and Ad Reinhardt used variants of the expression many years later. Attributions to Moliere and Virginia Woolf seem to be much weaker. Thank you for your question. Good luck to writers who are compensated and uncompensated.
Many thanks to Jonathan Caws-Elwitt whose provided inspiration for this investigation. The question was fictionalized, e. Knopf, New York. Google Books snippet; Verified on paper. Google News archive.
Google Books snippet; GB has incorrect ; Verified on paper. Google full view. The excerpt is modified to use the correct spelling] Google Books snippet; Verified on paper. First published ; Verified in paperback edition published Online Time magazine archive; Accessed January 17 link. Accessed January 17 link. Project MUSE link. Virginia Woolf? Philippe Halsman? Ad Reinhardt? Here is one version: Writing is like sex. But it is an unusually frank admission that he has at times pandered to the public taste … In a version of the saying appeared van buren palmerston prostitution the s of the New York newspaper The Village Voice.
The eleventh rule stated the following [AR]: Further below an excerpt van buren palmerston prostitution a memoir by the actor Leonard Nimoy provides additional evidence that Halsman has used the saying https://alatkantor.site/rss.xml: One comedian par excellence has disguised himself for years as a photographer.
Philippe had this answer for panel chairman Harriet Shepard in when she asked him why he became a photographer: Well, I drifted into photography like one drifts into prostitution. No specific citation was given in the reference, and the words differed from the earliest version given above [ODLQ]: Ferenc Molnar when asked how he became a writer In the same way that a woman becomes a prostitute.